The 40-Minute Gas Station Argument That Led to MURDER | Utah Case A Utah mother disappeared on New Year’s Day after meeting her former boyfriend. Days later, investigators found her remains in a remote area of Tooele County. In another Utah community, a 21-year-old woman left home for a short walk to a neighboring ranch—and vanished.
In today’s episode of Southern Girl Crime Stories, we cover the murder of Talia Lee Benward, followed by the unsolved disappearance of Elizibeth “Lizzy” Jewel Green.
🔎 Featured Cases:
🕵 Talia Lee Benward — Kearns, Utah
On January 1, 2025, 31-year-old Talia Benward borrowed a car and met her former boyfriend, Nestor Oved Rocha-Aguayo, at a gas station in West Jordan. Surveillance footage captured an argument before they drove away together. When Talia failed to return and her family could not reach her, she was reported missing.
Investigators traced surveillance footage, cellphone records, and evidence inside the borrowed Volkswagen Jetta. Their search led to a remote area of Tooele County, where a search dog located Talia’s remains on January 4. The medical examiner determined she died from asphyxiation and blunt force trauma.
Authorities arrested Rocha-Aguayo the following day after locating him aboard a bus bound for Mexico. On January 14, 2025, prosecutors charged him with aggravated murder, aggravated kidnapping, three counts of obstruction of justice, and abuse or desecration of a human body.
This episode examines Talia’s life, the documented history of domestic violence preceding her death, and the investigation that brought an arrest. Talia was a mother, daughter, sister, and devoted member of Utah’s lowrider community.
The charges are allegations. Rocha-Aguayo is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in a court of law.
🕵 Elizibeth “Lizzy” Jewel Green — Callao, Utah
On April 17, 2024, 21-year-old Lizzy Green reportedly left her family’s home around noon to walk to a cleaning job at a nearby ranch. The trip should have taken about ten minutes, but the ranch reported that she never arrived.
Search crews, tracking dogs, neighbors, and helicopters searched the surrounding desert without locating her. Her phone was off, her social media activity stopped, and important personal documents remained at home.
Investigators examined her digital accounts, including previously unknown online activity, while the FBI joined the investigation. Questions remain about whom Lizzy may have been communicating with and what happened after she reportedly left home. No explanation has been established.
Lizzy was last seen wearing a pink tie-dye hoodie, light blue jeans, black Converse sneakers, and a white backpack purse. In the episode’s November 2026 account, she remains missing.
This episode follows two Utah families searching for justice and answers—and remembers the women at the center of these cases.
📞 Have Information?
Elizibeth “Lizzy” Green:
Juab County Sheriff’s Office: 435-856-0358
Juab County Sheriff’s Dispatch: 801-794-3970
Case number: 24JC0335
⸻
💬 Join the Discussion:
What stands out to you about these investigations? How can continued public attention help families searching for answers? Please keep comments respectful toward the victims and their loved ones, and distinguish established facts from theories.
⸻
✨ Join the Southern Girl Community
Don’t forget to like, subscribe, and hit the notification bell so you never miss a case update.
👉 Subscribe:
https://www.youtube.com/c/SouthernGirlCrimeStories?sub_confirmation=1
👉 Unsolved Cases Playlist:
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLEgVw7wlWtzqWER3bquZo95HyfENaFeU
👉 Case Suggestions:
southerngirlcrimestories@gmail.com
Support the Channel:
👉 Patreon:
https://patreon.com/southerngirlcrimestories
☕ Buy Me a Coffee:
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/southerngi8
👉 PayPal:
https://www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=XENJPDT5MREMC
👉 Venmo:
https://www.venmo.com/u/southerngirlcrimestories
⸻
📚 Information Sources:
https://controlc.com/yxt6h9o9
⸻
🎵 Music Sources:
Day of Chaos — Kevin MacLeod
Finding the Balance — Kevin MacLeod
Anguish — Kevin MacLeod
Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0
Artist: https://incompetech.com/
⸻
#TrueCrime #SouthernGirlCrimeStories #TaliaBenward #ElizibethGreen #LizzyGreen #UtahTrueCrime #MissingPersons #UnsolvedDisappearance #JusticeForTalia #truecrimecommunity
⸻
🕒 Video Chapters
00:00 - The Last Sighting
00:38 - Southern Girl Crime Stories Intro
00:50 - Who Was Talia Benward?
01:06 - Abusive Boyfriend
02:32 - First Reentry
02:41 - The Break-In
03:19 - More Charges
04:08 - Second Reentry
04:17 - Day of the Murder
05:55 - Reported Missing
06:16 - Car Found
07:26 - Body Found
08:08 - The Arrest of Nestor
09:05 - Charges Filed
09:41 - What Happened to Elizibeth Green
11:45 - Reported Missing
12:29 - Theories
13:29 - A Secret Revealed
14:17 - Information Regarding Elizibeth